Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Clinical Microbiology, October 2002, p. 3648-3653, Vol. 40, No. 10
0095-1137/02/$04.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JCM.40.10.3648-3653.2002
Copyright © 2002, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
National Veterinary and Food Research Institute, Kuopio Department, FIN-70701 Kuopio,1 National Public Health Institute, Laboratory of Enteric Pathogens, FIN-00300 Helsinki, Finland2
Received 23 January 2002/ Returned for modification 11 April 2002/ Accepted 2 July 2002
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Serovar Agona has not been common in Finland. Of the serovar Agona strains isolated from humans, 69 to 100% have been from Finnish tourists who had been abroad preceding their salmonella infection (16). Only sporadic serovar Agona isolations (less than three annually) had been made among animals before 1994 (17). At the end of 1994, serovar Agona was isolated from cattle at two farms. Serovar Agona-infected cattle were detected at six additional farms in 1995. The farms involved in this outbreak were located in six governmental districts, four near the River Kalajoki in the province of Oulu (six farms) and two geographically nearby in the province of Vaasa (one farm each). The source for the outbreak was not found, and the time required for the elimination of the infection varied between less than 2 months (three farms) and more than 12 months (one farm) (1). Serovar Agona was the third most common salmonella serovar infecting cattle in Finland in 1995, after serovars Infantis and Typhimurium (17).
This study was undertaken to gather data on the molecular epidemiology of serovar Agona infections in animals and humans and to find out whether an increase in the number of animals found to be infected with this serovar has any effect on the number of cases of infection in humans caused by serovar Agona. During the study, a large human outbreak involving more than 50 cases of serovar Agona infection occurred in November and December 1999 (Fig. 1). The domestic outbreak was related to guests at the restaurant of a spa hotel in the region of Vaasa. Epidemiological investigations were carried out by local authorities, but the source of the outbreak remained unknown.
![]() View larger version (24K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Occurrence of domestic ( ) and imported ( ) human cases of Salmonella serovar Agona infection from 1999 through 2000.
|
|
|
|---|
The strains were isolated from cattle, animal feed, fur animals, humans, and other sources (Table 1) from 1984 to 1999. The first outbreak of serovar Agona infection among cattle in Finland occurred in 1994-1995 and involved eight farms. Isolates collected from these affected farms as well as other cattle isolates (n = 32) isolated from 1984 to 1999 and isolates (n = 28) from imported products, feed, fur animals and other animals, and sewage water were analyzed. The isolates from humans were classified by the Laboratory of Enteric Pathogens of KTL as either domestic (a patient had not been abroad during the month preceding the date when a specimen was taken) or foreign. Thirty of the human isolates had been associated with recent foreign travel. Isolates from sporadic cases of domestic origin from 1996 and 1997 and three isolates from an outbreak in 1999 involving over 50 people were also analyzed. All isolates had been serologically confirmed to be serovar Agona and stored at -70°C.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Origin and number of Salmonella serovar Agona isolates analyzed
|
molecular size ladder. DNA profiles differing by one or more DNA fragments were assigned a pulsed-field (pf) type number (XbaI restriction) or letter (other enzymes). The coefficient of similarity (F) values between the pf types were calculated as described previously (7). After visual analysis of the PFGE profiles, a computer program for analysis of electrophoretic patterns (GelCompar; Applied Maths, Kortrijk, Belgium) (24) was used to generate dendrograms.
Plasmid analyses. Plasmids smaller than 20 kb were isolated by the alkaline lysis method described by Grinsted and Bennett (9). The preparations were analyzed in 0.9% agarose gels (SeaKem LE; FMC Bioproducts, Rockland, Maine) at 4 V/cm for 1.5 h in 1x Tris-acetate-EDTA buffer (18), and the gels were stained with 0.5 µg of ethidium bromide per ml. Plasmids larger than 20 kb were analyzed by PFGE. The agarose plugs used for PFGE were treated with S1 nuclease, which linearizes plasmids (3), thereby making plasmid analysis and their size determination easier. S1 nuclease treatment was done at 37°C for 45 min in the reaction buffer supplied with the enzyme (code M576/1,2; Promega, Madison, Wis.). The analyses were performed with slices from the same agarose plugs used for chromosomal profiling by PFGE (see above). Escherichia coli strains V517 (plasmids of 35.6, 4.8, 3.7, 3.4, 1.8, and 1.4 MDa) (14) and 39R861 (plasmids of 98.0, 42.0, 23.9, and 4.6 MDa) (21) were used as plasmid reference strains in all alkaline lysis isolation procedures.
PCR for detection of IS200. The primer pair 5'-CCTAACAGGCGCATACGATC-3' and 5'-ACATCTTGCGGTCTGGCAAC-3' (4) and a 30-cycle program (1 min at 94°C, 0.5 min at 54°C, and 2 min at 72°C) were used to amplify a 557-bp PCR product of the IS200 insertion sequence. One of our own isolates of serovar Infantis (strain K1469) that was positive for IS200 was used as a control in all PCR runs.
Testing for microbial drug resistance. The agar diffusion test was performed as described by NCCLS with Oxoid (Basingstoke, United Kingdom) disks and Mueller-Hinton agar (Becton Dickinson and Company, Cockeysville, Md.). The disks contained 10 µg of ampicillin, 30 µg of cefotaxime, 30 µg of chloramphenicol, 5 µg of ciprofloxacin, 5 µg of enrofloxacin, 10 µg of streptomycin, 25 µg of sulfamethoxazole-trimethoprim, and 30 µg of tetracycline.
|
|
|---|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Distribution of the 39 XbaI profiles (pf1 to pf40) among 110 Salmonella serovar Agona isolates with respect to origin and year of isolation
|
![]() View larger version (32K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Dendrogram showing 39 pf profiles of Salmonella serovar Agona after XbaI restriction of chromosomal DNA followed by PFGE. Dice similarity coefficients are shown at the upper left; the molecular sizes (in kilobases) of the fragments are shown at the upper middle. XbaI profiles pf1 to pf40 and the number of isolates with the XbaI profile, as well as the human and cattle outbreak profiles, are indicated on the right.
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. Combined results after XbaI, BlnI, SpeI, and NotI restriction, plasmid analyses, and susceptibility testing for 39 representative isolates of Salmonella serovar Agona
|
Although the number of profiles obtained by digestion with any of these enzymes was not as large as the number obtained by digestion with XbaI, most of the BlnI, NotI, and SpeI profiles were seen in only one or two of the isolates analyzed (Table 3). However, the XbaI profiles seen in cattle isolates from 1994, 1995, and 1997 (profile pf1, pf2, pf3, and pf4 and profile pf21, pf22, and pf23) shared SpeI profiles A and J, respectively (Table 3). The differences between these two SpeI profiles, as well as between the BlnI and NotI profiles (Table 3), seen in these cattle isolates are minor (a one- to four-band difference) (data not shown).
As for the profiles seen in the isolates representative of the cattle outbreak (XbaI profiles pf1 and pf2) and the human outbreak (pf39) (Table 3), BlnI profile a1 resembled BlnI profile a but had an additional band (data not shown). There was also a one-band difference between SpeI profiles A and AD and NotI profiles N1 and N7 (data not shown).
Plasmid profiles. S1 nuclease analysis combined with PFGE showed that 35% (38 of 110) of the strains harbored plasmids larger than 20 kb (data for representative strains are shown in Table 3). Smaller plasmids with six different profiles (profiles a to f) were detected in 15% (16 of 110) of the isolates (Table 3).
Possession of IS200. The 557-bp product of IS200 was not amplified from any of the serovar Agona isolates. A strong and clear band of that size was always amplified from control strain K1469.
Antimicrobial resistance patterns. Of the 73 domestic isolates, only 1 isolate from a cattle farm (strain 2476) recovered in 1997 showed resistance to any of the antimicrobials tested (chloramphenicol and tetracycline; Table 3). Five of the 37 foreign isolates were resistant, and resistance to tetracycline and streptomycin was the most common (Table 3).
Combination of profiles. When representative isolates of each of the 39 XbaI profiles were analyzed with additional restriction enzymes (Table 3), the relatively large number of different profiles obtained with the additional enzymes (28, 21, and 21 profiles for BlnI, NotI, and SpeI, respectively) supports the existence of at least minor differences between the 39 XbaI profiles. The isolate representative of the human outbreak (XbaI profile pf39) did not seem to be related to any of the other isolates tested, whereas two groups (groups A and J) were formed among the cattle isolates by SpeI digestion. Large plasmids were seen in isolates comprising one-third (13 of 39) of the XbaI profiles and small plasmids were seen in isolates comprising one-fifth (8 of 39) of the XbaI profiles, but there seemed to be no connection between the PFGE profiles and plasmid profiles. All drug-resistant strains seemed to harbor large plasmids, thereby indicating the possibility of plasmid-mediated drug resistance in the isolates analyzed. Due to the large number of profiles obtained with all restriction enzymes applied in the study and the lack of an obvious connection between the PFGE and plasmid profiles, the material could not be divided into a few clear combination profile groups.
|
|
|---|
Among the typing methods applied in this study, PFGE proved to be the most useful. The serovar Agona isolates did not harbor any IS200 element, as has also been reported previously (8, 12), making this method inapplicable. It is also unlikely that serovar Agona can be subdivided by ribotyping (22). With few exceptions, the isolates were sensitive to all antimicrobials tested; thus, antibiograms did not provide useful epidemiological markers.
Threlfall et al. (22) described the application of PFGE with XbaI digestion to an international outbreak strain of serovar Agona. Different PFGE conditions prevent direct comparison of their results and ours, but serovar Agona seems to have many conserved restriction sites for the XbaI restriction enzyme, since many fragments are common between our different PFGE profiles. Double bands, i.e., bands containing two fragments of roughly the same size but visible as one thick band, are commonly produced from serovar Agona by digestion with XbaI. The presence of plasmids larger than 20 kb complicates the interpretation of banding patterns when the fragments generated are small, e.g., after digestion with NotI and SpeI, in which the fragment sizes are approximately 10 kb and higher.
We found a total of 39 different PFGE types by XbaI digestion of the 110 strains analyzed. The overall differences between the types were small, and most types were encountered in only one or two isolates. The importance of the ability to differentiate the isolates into that many subgroups can be questioned, and too many conclusions should perhaps not be drawn on the basis of the results obtained with only one restriction enzyme. Analysis with additional enzymes (BlnI, SpeI, and NotI), however, supported our findings that although the pf types by XbaI were highly similar, the differences seen cannot be disregarded. The situation was the opposite only for pf types pf1, pf2, pf3, pf4, pf21, pf22, and pf23, in which analysis with other enzymes in addition to XbaI supported our conclusions that these pf types are closely related.
Four XbaI profiles (profiles pf1, pf2, pf3, and pf4) were associated with serovar Agona infections on cattle farms in 1994-1995. These profiles were not previously seen among domestic or foreign isolates. pf1 was seen in the same area of northwestern Finland in slaughterhouse hygiene samples in 1996 (slaughterhouse B) and 1997 (slaughterhouse C) and in fur animals in 1996. Fur animals are often fed slaughterhouse waste, and although it is usually treated with heat or formic acid to avoid contamination, Salmonella is sometimes isolated from fur animals. Only one domestic human isolate of pf1 was detected, and it was in 1997, long after the outbreak in cattle.
Three XbaI profiles (profiles pf21, pf22, and pf23) seemed to be related to a small outbreak among cattle in Finland in 1997. The difference of three to six bands between these pf types and pf1 or pf2 can be explained by point mutations and suggests that the outbreaks in 1994-1995 and 1997 were possibly caused by related strains (15, 20). These three pf types (pf21, pf22, and pf23) share SpeI profile J. pf22 and pf23 also share BlnI profile o and NotI profile N14. Compared to XbaI profile pf21, the two additional bands (200 and 130 kb) of pf23 may have resulted from a point mutation. The molecular sizes of the additional bands add up to the molecular size of the missing band (330 kb) of pf23. All of these three pf types harbored one large plasmid, the size of which varied from 82 to 100 kb.
The outbreak among humans in 1999 occurred in the region of Vaasa, which is relatively close to the cattle farm outbreak in 1994-1995. There seemed to be a connection with fur animals, which were fed waste picked up from the restaurant associated with the human outbreak. One would therefore have thought it likely that profile pf1 or pf2 instead of a new profile, profile pf39, would have been detected in the human outbreak isolates. However, there is at least a seven-band difference between profiles pf1 and pf39, thereby indicating that the profiles are unrelated (15). pf1 was still seen in slaughterhouse isolates (slaughterhouse E) from 1999 in southeastern Finland, but on the basis of molecular typing, it is much more likely that the human outbreak in 1999 was not related to traces of the cattle farm outbreak in 1994-1995. Without detailed typing results, an infection route from cattle (1994) to fur animals (1996) and, finally, to humans (1999) would have easily been accepted as the cause of the human epidemic.
None of the isolates of foreign origin had XbaI profile pf1, pf2, pf3, pf4, pf21, pf22, or pf23, which were seen in domestic cattle isolates, nor did they have profile pf39, which was related to the restaurant-associated outbreak among humans in 1999. However, no recent foreign isolates were available, so a foreign source for the restaurant-associated outbreak that affected humans cannot be disregarded. The many XbaI profiles seen among the 30 human isolates of foreign origin (21 profiles, 14 of which were seen only among the foreign isolates) may reflect the heterogeneity of the worldwide serovar Agona infection. Five profiles (profiles pf5, pf16, pf24, pf27, and pf29) were also seen among human isolates of domestic origin. It cannot be excluded that some isolates were misclassified as foreign or that some infections classified as domestic in fact have a foreign origin.
In 1996, 1997, 1998, and 1999, four, seven, two, and one cattle farms, respectively, were serovar Agona positive (17). On the basis of the typing results for isolates recovered after those involved in the outbreak in 1994-1995, we suggest that a new strain invaded the area and caused the infections in cattle in 1994 and that, although we do not know where the original outbreak strain with XbaI profile pf1 or pf2 came from, it is highly likely that a closely related strain caused the infection among cattle in 1997. The outbreak among cattle in 1994-1995 was not associated with the outbreak among humans in 1999, nor does it seem to have affected the annual level of domestic serovar Agona infections among humans in Finland (16). The ability to make these conclusions shows the importance of knowing the molecular epidemiology of Salmonella infections occurring today.
We thank our colleagues Marja Fossi, Varpu Hirvelä-Koski, Sinikka Marmo, Tuija Saranpää, Raili Schildt, Erik Smeds, and Päivi Virtanen for providing the Salmonella isolates for the study. The skillful technical assistance of Tiina Jeulonen, Tiina Kortelainen, and Liisa Immonen is gratefully acknowledged.
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»