Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Clinical Microbiology, June 2003, p. 2577-2586, Vol. 41, No. 6
0095-1137/03/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JCM.41.6.2577-2586.2003
Division of Parasitic Diseases, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia 30341
Received 11 December 2002/ Returned for modification 23 January 2003/ Accepted 3 February 2003
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the life cycle of T. solium, humans are the definitive host for the adult worm and pigs are the intermediate host for the metacestode. Maintenance of the life cycle requires a close association between humans and pigs; consequently, this disease is found wherever pigs are allowed to roam freely to scavenge for food and humans lack adequate sanitary facilities for the disposal of feces. Cysticercosis is endemic in Latin America, India, Asia, and Africa (14, 36). A recent estimate of the prevalence of cysticercosis in Latin America indicated that 400,000 people have symptomatic disease (3).
Diagnosis of neurocysticercosis requires either imaging of the brain by computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging or the demonstration of cysticercosis-specific antibodies in the patient's serum. Brain imaging is expensive and is usually available only in urban centers within the countries where the disease is endemic. In addition, single lesions due to Mycobacterium tuberculosis are often difficult to distinguish from cysts due to T. solium (4, 9). Early antibody detection assays lacked sensitivity and specificity (7, 15, 29, 31), but in 1989, an assay with 98% sensitivity for the detection of cysticercosis cases with two or more cysts, less sensitivity for the detection of cases with single cysts (26, 28, 46), and 100% specificity was developed (40). The assay uses a partially purified preparation of metacestode antigens. Cysts harvested from pigs are solubilized in urea, and the bound fraction from lentil lectin affinity chromatography, the lentil lectin purified glycoproteins (LLGPs), is used as antigen in a Western blot or enzyme-linked immunoelectrotransfer blot assay. Immunoreactivity with any one of seven glycoproteins is diagnostic for cysticercosis. Since 1995, this has been the only assay recognized by the World Health Organization and the Pan American Health Organization for the serodiagnosis of cysticercosis (Pan American Health Organization and World Health Organization informal consultation on the taeniosis/cysticercosis complex, 1997). The assay, however, has some drawbacks. It is dependent upon a supply of naturally infected pigs. Preparation of the antigen and performance of the Western blot require considerable technical expertise. The partially purified LLGP antigen preparation is not suitable for use in an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) (V. C. W. Tsang, unpublished data); and a Western blot assay is not suitable for field studies, nor is it a suitable or affordable assay for diagnosis in countries where cysticercosis is endemic. To address these issues, we have been systematically characterizing the seven diagnostic LLGP antigens.
The characterization of two LLGP proteins, Ts14 and Ts18, has been reported earlier (16, 17). Here we report on the identification and characterization of a family of diagnostic proteins, the 8-kDa antigens of T. solium metacestodes. The 8-kDa antigens are the diagnostic proteins seen at 14, 18, and 21 kDa on the Western blot and are also found in the bands at 24 and 39 to 42 kDa. Eighteen unique mature proteins have been cloned by us and others (16, 24, 34) and were identified, by phylogenetic analysis, to sort into four clades. Nine were chemically synthesized for use as antigens. Testing of the synthetic proteins in an ELISA identified one 8-kDa protein with 100% sensitivity when it was tested with sera from cysticercosis patients reactive with the 8-kDa protein components of LLGP on Western blot and 100% specificity.
|
|
|---|
Amplification, cloning, and sequencing of the 8-kDa diagnostic antigens. The 8-kDa diagnostic antigens were amplified by using two sets of primers. Primers gTs14F (5'-ATGCGTGCCTACATTGTGCTTCTC-3') and gTs14R2 (5'-GCAGTTTTTTTCTTAGGACCTTTGCAGTG-3') amplified the gene for Ts14. The genes for the other 8-kDa proteins were amplified by using primers gTs14F and gTs14R1 (5'-GTGAAGAGAAGAACGCATGAAAGTTG-3'). All PCRs were done with Pfu polymerase (Stratagene, La Jolla, Calif.) at an annealing temperature of 60°C for 40 cycles. The amplicons were cloned into the vector PCR-Script (Stratagene) according to the instructions of the manufacturer. From 4 to 14 clones of each amplicon were sequenced. In addition, the amplicons resulting from amplification of DNA from the Peruvian isolate, the Indian isolate, and the China isolate with gTs14F and gTs14R2 were directly sequenced. In all cases, both strands of DNA were sequenced. All sequencing was done by terminator-based cycle sequencing with BIGDYE fluorescent dye (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, Calif.) (35) and an ABI Prism 377 DNA sequencer (Applied Biosystems).
Sequence data were analyzed with the SeqMan II program (DNASTAR Inc., Madison, Wis.). Sequence homology searches were done by using the BLAST program (1). Signal peptide sequences were predicted by using the SignalP program (23) along with N-terminal sequence data. Alignments were done by using the ClustalX program (39). For the phylogenetic analyses, all sequences were aligned, and the amino acid sequence data common to all sequences were used. The phylogenetic analysis was performed with the PUZZLE program (38), by the FITCH method (a least-squares distance method), and by the protein parsimony (protpars) method (http://evolution.genetics.washington.edu/phylip.html). Phylogenetic trees were displayed and manipulated by using the TreeView program (25).
Nine of the 8-kDa proteins were chemically synthesized, all with a long-chain biotin at the mature N terminus for uniform capture by streptavidin-coated polystyrene "sticks." Proteins Ts18, Ts18 var1, Ts18 var3, Ts18 var4, Ts18 var6, and TsRS2 var1 were synthesized by SynPep (Dublin, Calif.), and proteins Ts14, Ts18 var8, and TsRS1 were synthesized by AnaSpec Inc. (San Jose, Calif.). All were of at least 95% purity, as determined by high-pressure liquid chromatography. The mass of each synthetic protein, as determined by mass spectrometry, matched the theoretical mass. Synthetic proteins were solubilized in 0.05 M HEPES-0.1 M NaCl-2 mM dithiothreitol (pH 7.0) and stored at -80°C after the addition of glycerol to a final concentration of 43.5%. The protein concentration was determined by the bicinchoninic acid method (Pierce, Rockford, Ill.) (37).
Battery of serum samples. Our battery of serum samples included 32 T. solium-infected serum samples from patients with neurocysticercosis, 34 serum samples from patients with other parasitic infections, and 15 normal human serum samples (NHSs). All 32 serum samples from patients with T. solium infections were positive for cysticercosis by the LLGP Western blotting assay and all were reactive with the 8-kDa group of antigens (40). Many of the samples were also confirmed to be positive for cysticercosis by brain imaging or biopsy. A positive reference standard was formed by pooling sera from three patients with parasitologically confirmed, immunoblot-positive cysticercosis. The other parasitic infection serum samples were all from parasitologically confirmed cases. Among these serum samples were 4 serum samples from patients with Taenia saginata infections, 3 serum samples from patients with Echinococcus multilocularis infections, 6 serum samples from patients with Echinococcus granulosus infections, 11 serum samples from patients with Ascaris lumbricoides infections, 4 serum samples from patients with Schistosoma mansoni infections, 4 serum samples from patients with Schistosoma haematobium infections, and 2 serum samples from patients with Trichinella sp. infections. The NHSs were obtained from healthy U.S. residents who did not have a history of international travel.
Fast-ELISA. Fast-ELISA was performed as described previously (18). Streptavidin (recombinant streptavidin; Roche Molecular Biochemicals, Indianapolis, Ind.) was used to coat the polystyrene sticks of the Falcon 3931 assay screening test (Becton Dickinson, Lincoln Park, N.J.) at a saturating concentration of 6.0 µg of streptavidin per ml of 0.05 HEPES- 0.1 M NaCl (pH 7.0). The wash buffer and diluent buffer for the biotinylated proteins and conjugate was 0.05 M HEPES-0.1 M NaCl (pH 7.0) plus 0.3% Tween 20 (Calbiochem-Novabiochem Corp., La Jolla, Calif.). The serum diluent consisted of the same buffer with 5% nonfat dry milk. The biotinylated proteins were diluted to 1.0 µg/ml. The serum samples were assayed in triplicate at 1:100 dilutions. Bound antibodies were detected with a peroxidase-labeled goat anti-human immunoglobulin (41), followed by the substrate SureBlue (Kirkegaard & Perry Laboratories, Inc., Gaithersburg, Md.). All reagents except the sera were present in excess. After 5 min, the A650 was read with a ThermoMax microplate reader (Molecular Devices Corp., Sunnyvale, Calif.). Each plate contained a positive reference standard, which was used to calculate a relative absorbance unit for each sample by dividing the mean A650 for each sample by the mean A650 for the positive reference standard. As a control, the positive reference standard was included as a sample in the assay. If the relative absorbance for the control differed from 1.0 by more than 10%, the data for the plate were discarded.
Nucleotide sequence accession numbers. The nucleotide sequences identified in this study have been submitted to GenBank, and the accession numbers are given in Table 1.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Members of the 8-kDa family of proteins
|
|
|
|---|
Twenty-six unique sequences that encode 23 unique protein sequences were detected among the 32 nucleic acid sequences. These 8-kDa proteins have a signal sequence, cleavage of which results in a 66- or 67-amino-acid mature protein with a predicted molecular mass of about 8 kDa (
= 7,628 for the 66-amino-acid proteins and 7,746 for the 67-amino-acid proteins) and a predicted pI of about 9 (
= 8.96). There are 18 unique mature protein sequences. Within the mature protein sequence, all of the 8-kDa proteins have from one to three predicted N-linked glycosylation sites, and all of the 8-kDa proteins have one to three cysteines except for the proteins within the TsRS1 clade. These proteins lack N-linked glycosylation sites and cysteines. The 8-kDa proteins are hydrophilic, as determined by hydrophobicity analysis (21). They lack potential transmembrane regions and glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchor attachment sites (8). These data suggest that the 8-kDa proteins are extracellular secreted proteins that perhaps accumulate in the cyst fluid.
The 8-kDa proteins have been shown by protein sequencing to be the diagnostic proteins found at 14, 18, and 21 kDa in the lentil lectin bound fraction from urea-solubilized cysticerci (17, 40; data not shown). Only 8-kDa proteins have been found in these diagnostic bands. Protein sequencing data also show that the bands at 24 and 39 to 42 kDa contain 8-kDa proteins (27; data not shown). In addition, a polyclonal antibody raised against Ts14 reacts with the diagnostic bands at 14, 18, 21, 24, and 39 to 42 kDa (16). Reduction of the proteins in the diagnostic band from 39 to 42 kDa with dithiothreitol yields proteins migrating at 14, 18, and 21 kDa, suggesting that the 8-kDa proteins in the band from 39 to 42 kDa are disulfide-bonded multimers (17, 27; data not shown).
The 23 sequences were aligned by using the ClustalX program (Fig. 1A). The predicted signal peptide sequences are shown in italics and, as expected, are well conserved. Within the mature sequences, there are 12 absolutely conserved amino acids, 20 positions with more conservative substitutions, and 7 positions with less conservative substitutions. Among these 23 protein sequences, 18% of the amino acids are identical and 68% are similar or identical. Many of these identical and similar amino acids are clustered in the central portion of the mature protein, from position 27 through position 41.
![]() View larger version (63K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Alignments of the T. solium 8-kDa diagnostic antigens obtained with the ClustalX program. (A) Alignments of the 23 unique protein sequences from the 8-kDa gene family, identified by GenBank accession number. The predicted signal peptides are in italics. The lines between accession numbers mark the division of the sequences into four groups, Ts14, Ts18, TsRS1, and TsRS2. Additional protein sequences that are not shown are those with GenBank accession numbers AF257776 and AF158184, which are identical to the sequence with GenBank accession number AF082829; those with GenBank accession numbers AF356366 and AF356338, which are identical to the sequence with GenBank accession number AF356335; that with GenBank accession number AF356330, which is identical to the sequence with GenBank accession number AF098073; that with GenBank accession number AF356345, which is identical to the sequence with GenBank accession number AB044081; and those with GenBank accession numbers AF356342, AF163972, and AF356341, which are identical to the sequence with GenBank accession number AB044083. For this analysis, an intron-like sequence in the sequence with GenBank accession number AB044083 was removed. (B) Alignments of the 8-kDa proteins with the hydrophobic ligand-binding proteins of H. diminuta (GenBank accession number AF249884) and M. expansa (GenBank accession number AF312736). Asterisks mark identical amino acid residues. More and less conservative substitutions are indicated by two dots and one dot, respectively.
|
![]() View larger version (20K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Phylogenetic tree for the 8-kDa diagnostic antigens of T. solium. The analysis was done by quartet puzzling using a Clustal alignment of 73 amino acids from the 16 8-kDa proteins that are unique over the aligned sequence. The sequences are identified by GenBank accession number. The dashed ovals show the grouping of the sequences into four clades, Ts14, Ts18, TsRS1, and TsRS2. The scale bar indicates an evolutionary distance of 0.1 amino acid per position.
|
Phylogenetic analysis was done with the 13 homologous proteins plus 13 of the 8-kDa proteins, from all four clades, which aligned over 62 amino acids, as determined with the ClustalX program. The analysis was done by quartet puzzling, the FITCH method, and the protpars method. All methods gave trees with similar topologies. The quartet puzzling results are shown as a radial tree in Fig. 3. The sequences fall into five clades. The T. solium 8-kDa clade is the closest in evolutionary distance to the cestode hydrophobic ligand-binding proteins. The next closest clade consists of two T. solium sequences, one of which encodes a cysticercosis-specific antigen (GenBank accession number AF076609) and the other of which encodes an oncosphere-specific antigen (GenBank accession number AF523312), and one Taenia crassiceps sequence, which encodes an immunodiagnostic antigen (GenBank accession number U07150). The remaining eight sequences, which formed two clades, were all E. granulosus antigen B sequences. The node support values for the five clades ranged from 84 to 100%.
![]() View larger version (12K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Phylogenetic tree for the T. solium 8-kDa proteins and related sequences. The analysis was done by quartet puzzling using a Clustal alignment of 62 amino acids from 26 sequences. The T. solium 8-kDa antigen clades Ts14, Ts18, TsRS1, and TsRS2 are identified. The other sequences are identified by GenBank accession number, as follows: AF249884, H. diminuta hydrophobic ligand-binding protein; AF312736, M. expansa hydrophobic ligand-binding protein; AF362443, AF362444, S41921, S41922, S41923, S41924, U15001, and AF252859, all E. granulosus antigen B; AF523312, T. solium oncosphere-specific antigen; U07150, T. crassiceps immunodiagnostic antigen; and AF076609, T. solium cysticercosis-specific antigen. The scale bar indicates an evolutionary distance of 0.1 amino acid per position.
|
![]() View larger version (29K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Antibody reactivities of T. solium 8-kDa proteins. Eight of the T. solium 8-kDa proteins were assayed with a panel of defined serum samples: 32 serum samples from patients positive (pos) for cysticercosis, 34 serum samples from patients with other parasitic infections (other), and 15 NHSs. Relative absorbance units (RAU) are shown on the y axis. The J index for each antigen, calculated at 100% specificity, is shown.
|
![]() View larger version (13K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Comparisons of the antibody reactivities of the cysticercosis-positive serum samples. (A) Antibody reactivities of cysticercosis-positive serum samples, in relative absorbance units (RAU), with Ts18 var1 compared to the antibody reactivities of cysticercosis-positive serum samples with Ts18 var3. (B) Antibody reactivities of cysticercosis-positive serum samples with Ts18 var1 compared to the antibody reactivities of cysticercosis-positive serum samples with TsRS1. The r2 value for each line is shown.
|
|
|
|---|
There are at least two additional immunodiagnostic proteins in the LLGP antigen used in the Western blot. These are the protein at 50 kDa (GP50) and the non-8-kDa proteins at 24 and 39 to 42 kDa. While at least 90% of people with cysticercosis have antibodies that recognize more than one band in the immunoblot (40), the sera of some individuals recognize only GP50 and only the 24- or 42-kDa protein. Clearly, an assay that uses synthetic and recombinant antigens and that has the sensitivity of the LLGP Western blot assay must also include GP50 and the 24- and 42-kDa proteins. A recombinant antigen has been developed for GP50, and work is under way to develop a recombinant antigen for the 24- and 42-kDa proteins.
The 8-kDa antigens are not the first cloned proteins to be tested for their immunoreactivities with cysticercosis-infected sera. Hubert et al. (19) identified two proteins, NC-3 and NC-9, by screening a cDNA expression library with cysticercosis-positive sera. They expressed these proteins as glutathione S-transferase fusion proteins and tested them in an ELISA. NC-3 had a sensitivity of 96.3% and a specificity of 91.5%. The sensitivity of NC-9 was only 33.3%. Chung et al. (5) cloned and expressed the T. solium homolog of the T. crassiceps 10-kDa immunodiagnostic antigen (GenBank accession numbers AF076609 and U07150, respectively). These proteins are phylogenetically related to the T. solium 8-kDa antigens (Fig. 3). When expressed as a glutathione S-transferase fusion protein and tested in an immunoblot, the T. solium 10-kDa protein showed a sensitivity of 88% and a specificity of 98%.
Aside from these proteins, two of which are unrelated to the T. solium 8-kDa proteins and one of which is related to the T. solium 8-kDa proteins, Sako et al. (34) cloned and expressed three 8-kDa proteins, Ag1, Ag1V1, and Ag2 (GenBank accession numbers AB044080, AB044081, and AB044082, respectively). Ag1 is a member of the TsRS2 clade, Ag1V1 is in the Ts18 clade, and Ag2 is in the TsRS1 clade (Fig. 2). They used thioredoxin- and histidine-tagged-fusion proteins and reported low levels of antibody reactivity with Ag1 and good antibody reactivities with Ag1V1 and Ag2. For analysis in an ELISA, they expressed a histidine-tagged fusion of a chimera of Ag1V1 and Ag2 and reported a sensitivity of 89.7% and a specificity of 100%. These results are similar to the ones reported here. TsRS2 var1 (GenBank accession number AF356343) was the least sensitive of the synthetic proteins tested, and TsRS1 (GenBank accession number AF082830) was the most sensitive (Fig. 4). However, we report a sensitivity of 100% with synthetic TsRS1.
While other cloned proteins function as immunodiagnostic proteins, such as NC-9 and the T. solium 10-kDa protein, there is an advantage to targeting the diagnostic proteins of an antigen mixture that has been used successfully around the world for more than 10 years. These proteins have a track record of success when used for immunodiagnosis, with a sensitivity of 98% and a specificity of 100% (6, 12, 13, 40, 42, 46). Because it is known that the native proteins are glycoproteins, the one concern is the potential contribution of the carbohydrate moiety to the antibody response observed in cysticercosis patients. This concern was addressed by Obregon-Henao et al. (24), and their data showed diminished antibody activities for the native 8-kDa proteins following deglycosylation. However, our data for the synthetic 8-kDa proteins and the data of Sako et al. (34) for the recombinant 8-kDa proteins clearly show that the majority of the antibody reactivity is retained in proteins lacking glycosylation.
To be able to implement cysticercosis control programs, it is essential to have an accurate and rapid assay for diagnosis. While the LLGP Western blot assay is the "gold standard" assay for sensitivity and specificity (26a, 28), an ELISA format is much preferred because of its ease of use and lower cost. The use of cloned antigens rather than partially purified native proteins makes use of the ELISA format feasible and opens the possibility for the use of other rapid test formats, such as lateral flow assays. In addition, the use of a cloned protein as antigen removes the dependence on a supply of naturally infected pigs as a source of parasite material. The ability to chemically synthesize the antigen rather than express it greatly simplifies the process for obtaining antigen and keeps the cost low. The cost of synthetic TsRS1 antigen required to assay a single sample is $0.03. It may be possible to reduce this cost further by epitope mapping TsRS1 to determine if a smaller peptide(s) retains the same sensitivity for the detection of cysticercosis-positive sera.
The 8-kDa proteins are a family of secreted proteins that elicit an antibody response in infected people. The question arises, what is the function of these proteins in the metacestode? The best clue that we have is that phylogenetically they are the proteins most closely related to the cestode hydrophobic ligand-binding proteins, characterized in M. expansa (GenBank accession number AF312736), the sheep tapeworm, and in H. diminuta (GenBank accession number AF249884), the rat tapeworm (2, 20, 33) (Fig. 3). Like the cestode hydrophobic ligand-binding proteins, the 8-kDa proteins all have a conserved tryptophan that has been shown to be essential to the function of the cestode hydrophobic ligand-binding proteins (2, 32). This conserved tryptophan is not present in the members of the three other clades of phylogenetically related proteins (Fig. 3). On the basis of these similarities, we believe that the T. solium 8-kDa proteins may also be hydrophobic ligand-binding proteins, but ones that function as extracellular carrier proteins for lipids and other hydrophobic ligands. However, the possibility that the 8-kDa proteins may play a role in the host immune response, like the role proposed for the related protein antigen B from E. granulosus, should also be considered (30).
In the host-parasite interactions that occur during infection with T. solium metacestodes, it is clear that the 8-kDa proteins elicit an antibody response that is diagnostic for cysticercosis. In order to determine which flavor of the 18 8-kDa proteins identified to date works best as a diagnostic antigen, 9 of the 66- and 67-mer mature 8-kDa proteins were chemically synthesized and then evaluated in an ELISA. One, TsRS1, was 100% sensitive when it was tested with cysticercosis-positive sera reactive with the 8-kDa proteins on Western blot and was 100% specific. Two others, Ts18 var1 and Ts18 var3, were 97% sensitive and 100% specific and often showed different levels of antibody reactivity with cysticercosis-positive sera compared to the reactivity of TsRS1. TsRS1 and either Ts18 var1 or Ts18 var3 will be components of a diagnostic antigen cocktail of three to four synthetic and recombinant proteins, all derived from the diagnostic proteins used for the LLGP Western blot assay. Identification of these diagnostic antigens and the development of the ELISA are major steps forward for the serodiagnosis of cysticercosis.
We thank our collaborators H. Hugo Garcia, A. Emico Gonzalez, and Robert H. Gilman and all members of the Cysticercosis Working Group in Peru for providing the cysts from Peru. We also thank Hai-Chou Xue for providing the cysts from China and Vedantam Rajshekhar for providing the cysts from India. In addition, we are grateful to Norman J. Pieniazek for providing guidance for the phylogenetic analyses.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»