Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Clinical Microbiology, July 2006, p. 2434-2441, Vol. 44, No. 7
0095-1137/06/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/JCM.00397-06
Copyright © 2006, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Department of Epidemiology, University of Michigan School of Public Health, Ann Arbor, Michigan,1 Department of Pediatrics and Communicable Diseases, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, Michigan2
Received 22 February 2006/ Returned for modification 10 April 2006/ Accepted 10 May 2006
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
One critical aspect leading to UTI is the ability of UPEC strains to move from the intestinal tract and establish themselves in the urinary tract. In some cases this movement may be facilitated by UPEC strains establishing themselves first in the vagina (36, 37). Although some of this movement may be mechanical, the ability to establish colonization in the vagina and bladder must reflect bacterial characteristics. However, little is known about what genes or factors present in UPEC isolates help them move from the intestinal tract to the vagina and bladder and establish themselves extraintestinally.
Genomic subtraction makes it possible to identify genomic differences among strains. Genomic subtraction has been successfully employed to identify novel virulence-associated genes in UPEC strains (16, 22). We used a molecular epidemiologic strategy for bacterial gene discovery that selects bacterial isolates for genomic subtraction based on epidemiologic information and bacterial characteristics and screens epidemiologically defined bacterial collections with the resultant gene fragments to determine their potential significance and possible function (35, 44).
Here we report on the use of genomic subtraction followed by epidemiologic screening to identify 12 new genetic regions potentially involved in the spread of E. coli from the intestinal tract into the vagina and bladder.
|
|
|---|
PFGE. Purification, rare-cutter restriction, and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) of minimally sheared E. coli DNAs were performed as previously described (12). Briefly, electrophoresis of NotI-digested DNAs was done in a pulsed-field apparatus (DR III; Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA) in 1.3% SeaKem HGT agarose at 14°C with pulse ramping from 10 to 22 s for 14 h and from 55 s to 60 s for 8 h at a field strength of 6 V/cm. Gels were stained with Vistra green dye (Amersham Biosciences, Piscataway, NJ) and then scanned with a Storm phosphorimager (Molecular Dynamics, Sunnyvale, CA). The electrophoretic patterns were analyzed with BioNumeric software (Applied Maths, Kortrijk, Belgium).
Selection of strains for subtraction and screening. We used PFGE to define the identity of isolates from different sites within individual women and identified 102 women with UTIs and four women without UTIs who had the same E. coli strain colonizing the urine, rectum, and vagina. In one case a woman with a UTI had two separate PFGE-defined isolate types present at all three sites. Among women with an E. coli isolate with a single PFGE type present in all three sites, we also obtained E. coli isolates of different PFGE types from their rectal samples. Altogether, there were 381 isolates obtained from the 106 women. All 381 isolates had been screened previously for the presence of 13 virulence genes and assigned a virulence signature, i.e., a binary score based on the presence or absence of each virulence gene: type 1, P-pilus family of fimbriae (pff), S-fimbrial adhesion (sfa), aerobactin (aer), group II capsule (kpsMT), outer membrane protein T (ompT), hemolysin (hly), cytotoxic necrotizing factor 1 (cnf1), DR binding adhesions (drb), group III capsule (CAP III), and three subclasses of the P-pilus family of fimbriaepapGAD (class II), papGJ96 (class I), and prsGJ96 (class III) (11, 12, 20). We grouped the 381 isolates according to virulence signatures; the five largest groups ranged in size from 19 to 43 isolates (group 1= 1110111100010, n = 43; group 2 = 1000110000000, n = 26; group 3 = 1101110000100, n = 21; group 4 = 1001110000000, n = 20; group 5 = 1010111100000, n = 19), representing 129 of the isolates which were derived from 40 women with UTIs and three women without UTIs. As group 2 contains the lowest number of known virulence genes, positive only for fim, kpsMT, and ompT, it had the greatest potential for identifying new virulence genes. In contrast, 27 isolates from 24 women with UTIs and one woman without a UTI had unique PFGE patterns and virulence signatures that were found only once. A dendrogram analysis of the 43 PFGE patterns seen from the five largest virulence signature groups plus the 27 patterns from the unique rectal E. coli isolate is shown in Fig. 1. A representative shared isolate with a group 2 virulence signature, T280 F2, was chosen as the tester for genomic subtraction. For the subtraction driver, we selected isolate T306F66, a member of the group of unique rectal isolates with the closest match to the virulence signature of the tester (fim, pff, aero, ompT), which was phylogenetically distant based on the PFGE analysis (Fig. 1).
![]() View larger version (90K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Dendrogram of 43 E. coli isolates from the five most common virulence signatures plus 27 E. coli isolates found as unique virulence signatures. The filled circles show the positions of subtraction tester isolate T280F2, and the filled squares show the positions of subtraction driver isolate T306F66. The choice of the strains shown in this dendrogram is detailed in Materials and Methods.
|
Differential cloning by subtraction PCR. We used a commercial kit (Clontech PCR-Select bacterial genome subtraction kit; Palo Alto, CA.) to identify gene fragments specific to the tester strain through differential cloning. The genomic DNA of the driver (T306F66) was subtracted from that of the tester (T280F2) following the manufacturer's protocols to obtain tester-specific DNA. Briefly, genomic DNA was isolated from tester and driver strains, purified using phenol-chloroform extraction, and digested with RsaI. Following purification of the digested DNA, the tester DNA was ligated with the adapter provided with the kit. The tester-specific DNA (sPCR) fragments were cloned into a pCR4-TOPO plasmid vector using the TOPO TA cloning kit (Invitrogen) and transformed into TOP10. The transformants were tested for inserts by a nested PCR using nested primers supplied with the genomic subtraction kit. For three of the clones, the resulting PCR products contained additional vector sequences, and for these clones an alternative approach to obtain regions lacking vector sequence was used. This involved a two-step process: first, amplification with M13 and T7 primers (35 cycles of 94°C for 30 s, 55°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 2 min) followed by a nested PCR with primers provided with the subtraction kit (25 cycles of 94°C for 30 s, 68°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 2 min).
The sPCR products were spotted on nylon membranes and probed with fluorescence-labeled tester genomic DNA and driver genomic DNA using a commercially available kit (ECF random prime labeling and detection kit; Amersham). sPCR fragments that bound to both tester and driver DNA were removed from further analysis. Duplicate sPCR fragments were detected by cross-hybridization among all the tester-specific sPCR fragments, and only one of each was chosen for further analysis.
Data analysis.
Differences in proportions of genes among collections were tested using the
2 test. Prevalence ratios were calculated as the ratio between the proportion with the gene in the collection of interest and the proportion with the gene in the unique strains isolated from the rectal flora (reference group). The magnitude of the associations of the combination sJX genetic regions (sjx) with previously known UTI virulence genes was estimated using the odds ratio and 95% confidence intervals, and the significance was determined using the
2 test. All statistical analyses were performed using SAS (v9.1). P < 0.05 was considered to be statistically significant.
Nucleotide sequence accession numbers. The GenBank accession numbers for the sPCR fragments are as follows: sJX208, DU098706; sJX113, DU098707; sJX128, DU098708; sJX129, DU098709; sJX13, DU098710; sJX150, DU098711; sJX198, DU098712; sJX204, DU098713; sJX206, DU098714; sJX210, DU098715; sJX76, DU098716; sJX77, DU098717; sJX80, DU098718; sJX83, DU098719.
|
|
|---|
From the genomic subtraction of urine isolate T280F2 (tester) against the rectal isolate T306F66 (driver), we identified 185 sPCR fragments (Fig. 2). When separated by agarose gel electrophoresis, 60 of the sPCR products had multiple bands and were not considered further in the analysis. The remaining 125 sPCR fragments were each hybridized to labeled genomic DNA from the tester and driver strains to determine which were found in strain T280F2 but not in T306F66 (see Materials and Methods). Ninety-seven fragments were tester specific, and the genetic sequence was determined. As 97 was too large a number to reasonably screen, we selected one sPCR fragment representing each gene or operon, removing six sPCR fragments. We further reduced the number for screening by avoiding (i) genes that seemed to have housekeeping functions, (ii) genes present in the E. coli K-12 genome, (iii) already well characterized virulence genes, (iv) genes already found by one of our earlier subtractions that were already being analyzed (i.e., evgS), and (v) sPCR171, which had homology to a restriction-modification system. Finally, we preferentially chose sPCR fragments that were at least 350 bp, as larger probes work better technically in our dot blot hybridization system, although a few smaller sPCR fragments were tested. This left a total of 50 sPCR fragments. We used the 50 sPCR fragments to screen, using DNA dot blot hybridization, a collection of 88 uropathogens isolated from the rectum, urine, and vagina of women with UTIs and 54 E. coli isolates from the same women that were found only in the rectum. When isolates from multiple sites in a single woman were considered identical based on PFGE, only one of these isolates per woman was selected for screening. Figure 3A and B show a representative pair of dot blots for one of these probes. Figure 3C graphically represents the hybridization patterns for the duplicate blots. We used Southern blot analysis (Fig. 3D) to determine the appropriate cut point for classifying strains as containing or not containing sequences homologous to the sPCR probe. Similar analyses of all 50 sPCR probes identified 14 sPCR fragments present significantly more often in isolates colonizing multiple sites than in rectum-only isolates (Table 1).
![]() View larger version (26K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Flow diagram showing how 185 sPCR fragments were analyzed to result in the discovery of 14 being significantly more common in E. coli isolates obtained from multiple sites than in those E. coli isolates uniquely found in the rectum. The asterisk shows that 88 E. coli isolates were present in all three sites (urine, vagina, and rectum), and there were 54 rectum-only isolates from women who also had a different E. coli isolate present in more than one site.
|
![]() View larger version (51K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. (A and B) Duplicate dot blots (96 E. coli isolates) for probe sJX210. (C) Scatter plot of 96 E. coli isolates probed with sJX210 (A and B). Hybridization results are expressed as percentages of signal intensities of positive controls. Five isolates (see numbered circles in panel C) were chosen for Southern blot analysis: circle 1 surrounds duplicates of driver strain 306F66, and circle 2 (302F63), circle 3 (6F62), circle 4 (C658F66), and circle 5 surround duplicates of tester strain 280F2. (D) Southern blot assay using probe sJX210 with isolates listed; lane M contains DNA size markers.
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Prevalence of sJX subtraction candidates among 88 E. coli isolates from multiple sites and 54 unique rectal isolates, prevalence ratio, and putative functional homologya
|
![]() View larger version (23K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Locations of 13 sJX subtraction sPCR fragments on the E. coli CFT073 map. Solid black boxes represent sPCR fragments present significantly more often in E. coli isolates found in the vagina, urine, and the rectum than in isolates found only in the rectum. Open triangles represent known virulence factors in CFT073.
|
Many additional complete or partial E. coli genomic sequences are now available. We looked for sequence matches to the 14 sPCR fragments listed in Table 1 among the following genomic sequences: three UTI strains, CFT073 (41), F11 (GenBank accession no. NZ_AAJU00000000), and UTI89 (8); one K1 neonatal meningitis strain, R282 (39); three enteropathogenic E. coli strains, B171 (GenBank accession no. NZ_AAJX00000000), E110019 (GenBank accession no. NZ_AAJW00000000), and E22 (GenBank accession no. NZ_AAJV00000000); one enteroaggregative E. coli strain, 101-1 (GenBank accession no. NZ_AAMK00000000); two enterohemorrhagic E. coli strains, O157:H7 (O157Sakai) (14) and EDL933 (27); one enteroinvasive E. coli strain, 53638 (GenBank accession no. NZ_AAKB00000000); two enterotoxigenic E. coli strains, B7A (GenBank accession no. NZ_AAJT00000000) and E24377A (GenBank accession no. NZ_AAJZ00000000); one human-colonizing strain, HS (GenBank accession no. NZ_AAJY00000000); and two laboratory strains, MG1655 (3) and W3110 (1, 15, 43). Table 2 shows what matches were found.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Percent sequence matches of sJX subtraction fragments to E. coli genomic sequencesa
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. Association of sjx (sJX77, -80, -83, -128, -129, -150, -204, and -208) with known UTI virulence genes among 88 E. coli isolates that include uropathogens isolated from urine (rectal, urine, and vaginal E. coli isolates identical by PFGE in a single woman) and 54 rectum-only isolates from the same individuals who had a different E. coli isolate present in multiple-site collections
|
|
|
|---|
Of the 14 resulting sPCR fragments found statistically significantly more often in E. coli isolates present in multiple sites than in those limited to the rectum, 13 had strong DNA homologies to sequences present in the genome of the completely sequenced pyelonephritis strain CFT073 (41) (Fig. 4). These 13 sPCR fragments appear to represent 11 different genetic regions, as sJX208 and sJX77 are located very close together and represent CFT073 genes C0021, C0022, and C0023, while sJX113 and sJX76 are found at different ends of the auf adhesin gene cluster (6).
These 12 new genetic regions (11 in CFT073 and 1 not in CFT073) are an interesting mixture of genes that seem to fit well into categories of known UTI virulence genes and those that are either less expected or of completely unknown function (Table 1). Adhesins make up a substantial portion of the demonstrated UPEC virulence functions, including type 1 pili (13), P fimbriae (19, 42), Dr family adhesins (24, 45), and S fimbriae (33). In addition to the auf gene cluster represented by sJX113 and sJX76, sJX80 contains portions of the yadL and yadM genes, which have been described as probable fimbrial genes (27). Another functional group well represented in known UPEC virulence factors is those involved in iron uptake, including the siderophore aerobactin (20, 38), synthesized by a set of iuc genes and transported by proteins encoded by iut genes; a siderophore receptor, IroNE. coli (2, 18, 20, 29), and three additional genes with homology to iron uptake systems have been reported by Rasko et al. (28) to be present more often in E. coli cystitis or pyelonephritis isolates than in fecal ones, and Parham et al. (25) have shown that these fbp genes are more common in prostatitis isolates than in cystitis or pyelonephritis isolates. Our study found two iron uptake genes that occurred more often in E. coli isolates present in multiple sites within a woman than in rectum-only isolates: sJX83, which is part of the C3775 gene encoding an outer membrane receptor involved in iron uptake (27), and sJX128, which contains part of the sitD gene, which encodes the iron transport protein SitD (41).
Some of the probes associated with colonization in multiple sites within a woman overlap genes with homologies to genes with known functions but which have not been previously associated with UPEC virulence and whose possible roles in multisite colonization are unclear. These include sJX206, which overlaps with C4894 (tsx) and C4895, where the Tsx protein is a minor component of the E. coli outer membrane that is essential for the uptake of deoxynucleosides and nucleosides at submicromolar substrate concentrations (23), and C4895, another gene involved in nucleoside metabolism. Tsx also serves as a receptor for colicins (5) and bacteriophage (30). sJX204 covers a portion of the C5080 (yddR) gene, which has homology to Yersinia genes involved in nickel transport into bacteria. Interestingly, in pathogenic Yersinia species these uptake genes are adjacent to the urease gene cluster, and mutants defective in nickel uptake cannot make functional urease (31). sJX198 overlaps C5433, which has homology to C4-dicarboxylate transport substrate binding genes, and C5434 encodes a hypothetical protein with no known homologies.
Eight of the 14 fragments occurred together in 73% of all isolates colonizing multiple sites but in only 22% of the rectum-only isolates. As the genes are spread throughout the CFT073 genome, this suggests that this combination of genes may be functionally linked. Further, the combination was strongly associated with several known UTI virulence factors, including cnf1, prsGJ96, hly, iroN, kpsMT, and sfa, especially among the collection of isolates from multiple sites, suggesting that extraintestinal movement is part of UPEC's armamentarium.
Since this is the first report of an association of these regions with UTI strains specifically, there is always a possibility that one or more of them occurred by chance alone in our analysis. However, the observation that most of these were uniquely present in the sequenced UTI and meningitis E. coli genomes compared to the other types of E. coli isolates that have been sequenced (Table 2) increases our confidence that these associations are real. It seems highly likely that our genomic subtraction has not found all of the genetic regions of interest in CFT073 or the other sequenced E. coli isolates that cause UTIs, as only 2 of the 12 new genetic regions were sampled twice in our sPCR set. The next useful approach will be to systematically do an "in silico" subtraction, where we determine all genes present in the majority of the UTI (and meningitis) strain genomes but absent in the majority of the commensal, laboratory, or diarrheal E. coli genomes. These genes can then be screened against large collections of UTI versus non-UTI isolates to determine those potentially important in uropathogenesis.
A limitation of the approach described here is that it does not find the more subtle differences between strains that will also be important in differentiating UPEC isolates from normal rectal E. coli isolates. Well-studied examples of these kinds of differences include phase variation of P pili (4) and type 1 fimbriae (13) and allelic sequence variations shown to be important in tissue specificity for P pili (42) and FimH (34).
The discovery of these 12 new genetic regions of E. coli that are more often found in E. coli isolates present in multiple sites within a woman than in rectum-only isolates is clearly just the first step in determining what roles the genes that they represent may play in UPEC virulence. Additional association studies to look at their distributions in different UTI collections are needed. Ultimately, functional studies and animal virulence model studies may help further define the roles played by these genes.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»