Previous Article | Next Article 
Journal of Clinical Microbiology, May 2008, p. 1854-1857, Vol. 46, No. 5
0095-1137/08/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/JCM.00105-07
Copyright © 2008, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Direct Comparison of the GenoType MTBC and Genomic Deletion Assays in Terms of Ability To Distinguish between Members of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis Complex in Clinical Isolates and in Clinical Specimens
Akos Somoskovi,1
Jillian Dormandy,1
Jeremy Rivenburg,1
Maria Pedrosa,2
Melinda McBride,2 and
Max Salfinger1,2*
Wadsworth Center, New York State Department of Health, Albany, New York,1
Bureau of Laboratories, Florida Department of Health, Jacksonville, Florida2
Received 15 January 2007/
Returned for modification 18 March 2007/
Accepted 6 March 2008

ABSTRACT
The automated GenoType MTBC assay was evaluated for the ability
to detect and identify members of the
Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex. In addition to 35 reference strains and 157 clinical
isolates, performance of this assay was tested directly on 79
smear-positive clinical specimens. The assay proved as accurate
as the reference deletion analysis for all 192 isolates and
detected and identified
M. tuberculosis complex members in 93.2%
of the specimens containing the
M. tuberculosis complex.

TEXT
The
Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex is composed of the closely
related organisms
M. tuberculosis, M. africanum, M. bovis, and
M. bovis BCG and four other, rarely seen members,
M. caprae, M. microti, M. canettii, and
M. pinnipedii (
3,
5). Rapid and
reliable identification of the members of the
M. tuberculosis complex is critical in guiding public health and primary care
decisions. This is because each organism exhibits a different
epidemiology, host spectrum, geographic range, pathogenicity,
and drug susceptibility (
14). Recently, comparative genomics
of the
M. tuberculosis complex identified several regions (regions
of difference; RD), ranging in size from 2 to 12.7 kb, that
were present in
M. tuberculosis H37Rv and absent in other members
of the
M. tuberculosis complex. These results suggested that
deletion of genomic regions has been important in generating
genetic diversity within the complex (
3,
14). Based on these
findings, our laboratory developed a rapid PCR-based genomic
deletion analysis, using six RDs that are either common to various
members of the
M. tuberculosis complex or specific to each one.
This approach was based on an initial screening for RD1, RD9,
and RD10, with a reflex test for RD3, RD5, and RD11 (
14). To
further improve and simplify this method, we later replaced
the reflex panel with assays targeting RD4 and RD12; this modified
assay was validated with 1,685
M. tuberculosis complex clinical
isolates (
15). More recently, a multiplex PCR-based, solid-phase
reverse hybridization GenoType MTBC assay (Hain Lifescience
GmbH, Nehren, Germany) was developed, based on the detection
of single nucleotide polymorphisms of the
gyrB gene and on the
presence or absence of RD1 (
17,
18). This assay provides a rapid
and accurate method to identify the presence of various members
of the
M. tuberculosis complex (
8,
13,
17,
18) when it is used
with growth-positive cultures. The first goal of the present
study was to evaluate the automated version of the GenoType
MTBC assay on a set of well-characterized reference strains
and a large number of clinically significant isolates, using
PCR-based deletion analysis as a reference method. The second
goal of the study was to determine the sensitivity and accuracy
of the GenoType MTBC assay when it was used directly on smear-positive
clinical specimens.
A total of 35 phenotypically and genetically well-characterized (10, 14, 15, 21) reference mycobacterial strains and 157 clinical M. tuberculosis complex isolates, which were obtained from samples submitted to the Wadsworth Center, were used in the study (Table 1). In addition, 79 acid-fast bacillus smear-positive specimens were analyzed. These included 59 clinical specimens that had been received for routine mycobacterial testing between January 2002 and June 2007 and that had been shown to be M. tuberculosis complex positive (Wadsworth Center) and 20 clinical specimens that had been shown to be M. tuberculosis complex negative (Florida Bureau of Laboratories) by Amplified MTD (Mycobacterium tuberculosis direct) tests (Gen-Probe Incorporated, San Diego, CA). Only one specimen per patient was used in the present analysis. The specimens were initially digested and decontaminated by a modified Petroff's NaOH method (Wadsworth Center) and by a NALC-NaOH method (Florida Bureau of Laboratories) (10, 21). Smears were prepared with 0.1 ml of the concentrated sediment, using the Ziehl-Neelsen acid-fast staining method (10). The grade of smear positivity was available retrospectively for 55 specimens, as follows: numerous, 16 specimens (29.1%); moderate, 11 specimens (20.0%); few, 18 specimens (32.7%); and rare, 10 specimens (18.2%). After inoculation for growth detection (BACTEC 12B/MGIT 960 and Lowenstein-Jensen Gruft), the leftover sediment was stored at –80°C. Growth detection for mycobacteria and identification of members of the M. tuberculosis complex by PCR-based deletion analysis of acid-fast growth-positive cultures were performed as described below.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 1. M. tuberculosis complex and NTM reference strains and clinical M. tuberculosis complex isolates examined in this study
|
For clinical specimens, the GenoType MTBC assay was carried
out as described below, with the following modifications (
1).
One milliliter of decontaminated and concentrated specimen was
centrifuged at 10,000
x g for 15 min, the supernatant was discarded,
and the pellet was resuspended in 300 µl of sterile distilled
water. The specimen was then heat killed at 95°C for 20
min in a heat block. This was followed by a 15-min sonication
step in a Transsonic 460/H (Elma, Germany) sonicator. After
sonication, 5 µl of the supernatant was used immediately
for amplification, while the rest was stored at –20°C.
The growth medium was then incubated at 37°C and held for 6 to 8 weeks before the sample was reported as negative. When they were positive, the strains were identified as members of the M. tuberculosis complex by means of a PCR-based deletion analysis; non-M. tuberculosis complex mycobacteria were identified using PCR restriction analysis (23). Prior to amplification by PCR, 200-µl aliquots of reference strain cultures and growth-positive liquid cultures of clinical specimens were incubated at 80°C for 1 h to heat kill mycobacterial cells. Genomes of the isolates were then analyzed by PCR for the presence or absence of five regions (RD1, RD4, RD9, RD10, and RD12) as described earlier (14, 15). Three primers were included in each assay; two primers were specific for the sequences that flanked the region, and the third was specific for an internal sequence close to one of the flanking primers. The sizes of the PCR products were used to determine the presence or absence of each region. The primer sequences and PCR product sizes are listed in Table 2. Control molecular tests were performed with the M. tuberculosis H37Rv ATCC 2794 strain and with a master mix with distilled water used as a negative control.
For reference and clinical isolates, the GenoType MTBC assay
was carried out according to the manufacturer's instructions,
with 5 µl of heat-killed bacterial cells used in the amplification
mixture (
17,
18). Each biotin-labeled PCR product was denatured
and hybridized to a strip with 13 specific oligonucleotide probes,
using a heat-controlled washing and shaking automaton (GT-Blot
48; Hain Lifescience GmbH, Nehren, Germany). The specificity
and targeted genes (in parentheses) of the probes were as follows:
1, conjugate (hybridization) control; 2,
Mycobacterium genus-specific
amplification control (23S rRNA); 3,
M. tuberculosis complex-specific
probe for identification control (23S rRNA); 4 to 12, discriminative
for
M. tuberculosis complex species (
gyrB), and 13,
M. bovis BCG-specific probe (RD1). Six different patterns could be obtained
(
M. tuberculosis or
M. canettii, M. africanum, M. bovis, M. bovis BCG,
M. caprae, and
M. microti). An evaluation sheet showing
the positions of the lines and the interpretation table provided
with the kit were used to evaluate the GenoType MTBC results
as described elsewhere (
17,
18).
In the first phase of the study, the sensitivity and specificity of the GenoType MTBC assay were evaluated with a set of reference ATCC strains and other previously well-characterized strains of the M. tuberculosis complex (n = 25) and nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) (n = 10) (Table 1). With the exception of M. canettii, which was identified as M. tuberculosis, the GenoType MTBC test correctly identified all members of the M. tuberculosis complex. The specificity of the assay was 100%, since hybridization was detected only with the mycobacterium-specific probe when the NTM were tested.
In addition, a large number (n = 157) of clinical M. tuberculosis complex isolates (Table 1) were analyzed by the GenoType MTBC test; these had been identified by PCR-based deletion analysis (10, 14, 15, 21). Of these isolates, 38 (24.2%) were identified as M. tuberculosis, 47 (29.9%) were identified as M. africanum, 37 (23.6%) were identified as M. bovis, 34 (21.7%) were identified as M. bovis BCG, and 1 (0.6%) was identified as M. caprae. These results were in full agreement with the reference deletion analysis. In addition, both the GenoType MTBC test and the deletion analysis were able to readily identify M. tuberculosis and M. africanum in two mixed cultures that also contained M. avium.
Growth detection and PCR-based deletion analysis identified 48 M. tuberculosis, 6 M. africanum, 4 M. bovis, and 1 M. bovis BCG strain in the set of 59 smear- and MTD-positive specimens. The GenoType MTBC test correctly detected M. tuberculosis complex with the M. tuberculosis complex-specific capture probe in 58 (98.3%) of these 59 specimens. The GenoType MTBC test correctly identified the presence of M. tuberculosis in 44 (91.6%) of the 48 specimens containing M. tuberculosis and in all other specimens (Table 3). For four M. tuberculosis specimens (6.7%), amplification was unsuccessful for all three target regions (23S rRNA, RD1, and gyrB), presumably due to the presence of PCR inhibitors. We did not see any correlation with the grade of smear positivity in these four specimens.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 3. Results of GenoType MTBC assay used directly on 59 smear-positive and M. tuberculosis complex-positive clinical specimens
|
Growth detection and PCR restriction analysis identified 14
M. avium complex, 4
M. abscessus, and 2
M. kansasii strains
in the set of 20 smear-positive and MTD- negative specimens.
The GenoType MTBC test was correctly positive only for the conjugate
(hybridization) control and the
Mycobacterium genus-specific
amplification control (23S rRNA) with these specimens.
Previously, our laboratory developed a PCR-based genomic deletion analysis that facilitated the rapid, reliable, and routine identification of members of the M. tuberculosis complex (14). In the present study, the GenoType MTBC assay exhibited a sensitivity and specificity equal to those of our deletion analysis for all reference and clinical M. tuberculosis complex isolates, with the exception of M. canettii (Table 1). Thus, M. canettii cannot be differentiated from M. tuberculosis by the GenoType MTBC assay, but this test can differentiate M. canettii from other members of the complex (14). Alternatively, M. canettii can be identified rapidly by deletion analysis or by a recently identified M. canettii-specific silent mutation of the pncA gene (20). Both the GenoType MTBC test and our deletion analysis are simple to perform and can be incorporated easily into the routine clinical workflow. This is in contrast to other molecular methods (e.g., spoligotyping or DNA sequencing), which are not within the scope of many laboratories' capabilities and are less accurate in identifying members of the M. tuberculosis complex (7).
In addition, the GenoType MTBC assay provided a reliable direct detection method for identification of members of the M. tuberculosis complex for 93.2% of the smear-positive and M. tuberculosis complex-positive specimens (Table 3), with an excellent specificity, since none of the 20 smear-positive and MTD-negative specimens containing NTM gave a false-positive result for the M. tuberculosis complex or any members of the complex with the assay. The ability to differentiate accurately among the members of the M. tuberculosis complex has important public health and primary care ramifications. First, it allows health care professionals to better determine the level and target (humans or animals) of contact tracing and to exclude pyrazinamide from the treatment regimen in cases of M. bovis infection given this organism's natural resistance to pyrazinamide. Second, it can help physicians to identify severe side effects of M. bovis BCG treatment in patients with bladder cancer and in other immunocompromised patients (9, 19, 26). Third, it can help analysts to intercept the transmission link more rapidly in situations of outbreak due to M. bovis transmission between animal products and humans (4) or to reduce transmission of the disease between animals, especially if they belong to endangered species (2, 11). Lastly, it can help epidemiologists to accumulate more information on the epidemiology and clinical significance of various members of the complex in geographic areas where unusual members of the complex are more common than is currently recognized (6, 12, 16). Importantly, the turnaround time to detect and identify members of the M. tuberculosis complex with the GenoType MTBC assay can be well in line with the recommended 2 to 3 weeks by the CDC, especially when the test is used directly on clinical specimens (22, 24). The direct application of the assay to clinical specimens may also fulfill the Healthy People 2010 initiative, which recommends that the average time to confirm and report 75% of tuberculosis cases be within 48 h (25). A major advantage of the GenoType MTBC assay over deletion analysis is automation of the detection phase of the assay, which enables the parallel hybridization of 48 samples and makes this test highly suitable for laboratories managing large specimen loads.
In conclusion, the GenoType MTBC assay, though not yet U.S. FDA approved, is an automated, easy-to-use, and reliable method that can be used either in combination with broth-based culture systems or directly on smear-positive clinical specimens for the routine identification of members of the M. tuberculosis complex in any mycobacteriology laboratory.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank Hain Lifescience for providing some of the GenoType
MTBC assay kits.
M.M. was supported in part by an appointment to the Emerging Infectious Diseases (EID) Fellowship Program, administered by the Association of Public Health Laboratories (APHL) and funded by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

FOOTNOTES
* Corresponding author. Present address: Bureau of Laboratories, Florida Department of Health, 4052 Bald Cypress Way, A-15, Tallahassee, FL 32399-1716. Phone: (850) 245-4517. Fax: (850) 921-9906. E-mail:
Max_Salfinger{at}doh.state.fl.us 
Published ahead of print on 19 March 2008. 

REFERENCES
1 - Bang, D., A. Bengard Andersen, and V. O. Thomsen. 2006. Rapid genotypic detection of rifampin- and isoniazid-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis directly in clinical specimens. J. Clin. Microbiol. 44:2605-2608.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
2 - Briones, V., L. de Juan, C. Sanchez, A. I. Vela, M. Galka, Montero, J. Goyache, A. Aranaz, and L. Dominguez. 2000. Bovine tuberculosis and the endangered Iberian lynx. Emerg. Infect. Dis. 6:189-191.[Medline]
3 - Brosch, R., S. V. Gordon, M. Marmiesse, P. Brodin, C. Buchrieser, K. Eiglmeier, T. Garnier, C. Gutierrez, G. Hewinson, K. Kremer, L. M. Parsons, A. S. Pym, S. Samper, D. van Soolingen, and S. T. Cole. 2002. A new evolutionary scenario for the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 99:3684-3689.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
4 - Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2005. Human tuberculosis caused by Mycobacterium bovis—New York City, 2001-2004. MMWR Morb. Mortal. Wkly. Rep. 54:605-608.[Medline]
5 - Cousins, D. V., R. Bastida, A. Cataldi, V. Quse, S. Redrobe, S. Dow, P. Duignan, A. Murray, C. Dupont, N. Ahmed, D. M. Collins, W. R. Butler, D. Dawson, D. Rodriguez, J. Loureiro, M. I. Romano, A. Alito, M. Zumarraga, and A. Bernardelli. 2003. Tuberculosis in seals caused by a novel member of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex: Mycobacterium pinnipedii sp. nov. Int. J. Syst. Evol. Microbiol. 53:1305-1314.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
6 - Dankner, W. M., and C. E. Davis. 2000. Mycobacterium bovis as a significant cause of tuberculosis in children residing along the United States-Mexico border in the Baja California region. Pediatrics 105:E79.[CrossRef][Medline]
7 - Driscoll, J. R., L. M. Parsons, M. Salfinger, and H. W. Taber. 2005. Genomic analysis of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex: applications to laboratory diagnosis and genotyping. Rev. Med. Microbiol. 16:49-58.
8 - Gomez, M. P., L. Herrera-Leon, M. S. Jimenez, and J. G. Rodriguez. 2007. Comparison of GenoType MTBC with RFLP-PCR and multiplex PCR to identify Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex species. Eur. J. Clin. Microbiol. Infect. Dis. 26:63-66.[CrossRef][Medline]
9 - Gonzalez, O. Y., D. M. Musher, I. Brar, S. Furgeson, M. R. Boktour, E. J. Septimus, R. J. Hamill, and E. A. Graviss. 2003. Spectrum of bacille Calmette-Guerin (BCG) infection after intravesical BCG immunotherapy. Clin. Infect. Dis. 36:140-148.[CrossRef][Medline]
10 - Kent, P. T., and G. P. Kubica. 1985. Public health mycobacteriology. A guide for a level III laboratory. Centers for Disease Control, Atlanta, GA.
11 - Lantos, A., S. Niemann, L. Mezosi, E. Sos, K. Erdelyi, S. David, L. M. Parsons, T. Kubica, S. Rusch-Gerdes, and A. Somoskovi. 2003. Pulmonary tuberculosis due to Mycobacterium bovis subsp. caprae in captive Siberian tiger. Emerg. Infect. Dis. 9:1462-1464.[Medline]
12 - LoBue, P. A., W. Betacourt, C. Peter, and K. S. Moser. 2003. Epidemiology of Mycobacterium bovis disease in San Diego County, 1994-2000. Int. J. Tuberc. Lung Dis. 7:180-185.[Medline]
13 - Neonakis, I. K., Z. Gitti, E. Petinaki, S. Maraki, and D. A. Spandidos. 2007. Evaluation of the GenoType MTBC assay for differentiating 120 clinical Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex isolates. Eur. J. Clin. Microbiol. Infect. Dis. 26:151-152.[CrossRef][Medline]
14 - Parsons, L. M., R. Brosch, S. T. Cole, A. Somoskovi, A. Loder, G. Bretzel, D. Van Soolingen, Y. M. Hale, and M. Salfinger. 2002. Rapid and simple approach for identification of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex isolates by PCR-based genomic deletion analysis. J. Clin. Microbiol. 40:2339-2345.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
15 - Parsons, L. M., J. Dormandy, A. Clobridge, J. R. Driscoll, M. Oxtoby, H. W. Taber, and M. Salfinger. 2004. Deletion analysis: a novel and rapid genotyping method for speciation within the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex. Poster, Natl. TB Controllers Workshop. National TB Controllers Association and CDC, Atlanta, GA.
16 - Prodinger, W. M., A. Eigentler, F. Allerberger, M. Schonbauer, and W. Glawischnig. 2002. Infection of red deer, cattle, and humans with Mycobacterium bovis subsp. caprae in western Austria. J. Clin. Microbiol. 40:2270-2272.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
17 - Richter, E., M. Weizenegger, A. M. Fahr, and S. Rusch-Gerdes. 2004. Usefulness of the GenoType MTBC assay for differentiating species of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex in cultures obtained from clinical specimens. J. Clin. Microbiol. 42:4303-4306.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
18 - Richter, E., M. Weizenegger, S. Rusch-Gerdes, and S. Niemann. 2003. Evaluation of GenoType MTBC assay for differentiation of clinical Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex isolates. J. Clin. Microbiol. 41:2672-2675.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
19 - Somoskovi, A., C. Carlyn, J. Dormandy, and M. Salfinger. 2007. Mediastinal mass mimicking a tumor in a patient with bladder cancer after bacillus Calmette-Guerin treatment. Eur. J. Clin. Microbiol. Infect. Dis. 7:632-635.
20 - Somoskovi, A., J. Dormandy, L. M. Parsons, M. Kaswa, K. S. Goh, N. Rastogi, and M. Salfinger. 2007. Sequencing of the pncA gene in members of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex has important diagnostic applications: identification of a species-specific pncA mutation in "Mycobacterium canettii" and the reliable and rapid predictor of pyrazinamide resistance. J. Clin. Microbiol. 45:595-599.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
21 - Somoskovi, A., Q. Song, J. Mester, C. Tanner, Y. M. Hale, L. M. Parsons, and M. Salfinger. 2003. Use of molecular methods to identify the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC) and other mycobacterial species and to detect rifampin resistance in MTBC isolates following growth detection with the BACTEC MGIT 960 system. J. Clin. Microbiol. 41:2822-2826.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
22 - Styrt, B. A., T. M. Shinnick, J. C. Ridderhof, J. T. Crawford, and F. C. Tenover. 1997. Turnaround times for mycobacterial cultures. J. Clin. Microbiol. 35:1041-1042.[Medline]
23 - Taylor, T. B., C. Patterson, Y. Hale, and W. W. Safranek. 1997. Routine use of PCR-restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis for identification of mycobacteria growing in liquid media. J. Clin. Microbiol. 35:79-85.[Abstract]
24 - Tenover, F. C., J. T. Crawford, R. E. Huebner, L. J. Geiter, C. R. Horsburgh, Jr., and R. C. Good. 1993. The resurgence of tuberculosis: is your laboratory ready? J. Clin. Microbiol. 31:767-770.[Free Full Text]
25 - U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 2000. Healthy people 2010. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Washington, DC.
26 - Waecker, N. J., Jr., R. Stefanova, M. D. Cave, C. E. Davis, and W. M. Dankner. 2000. Nosocomial transmission of Mycobacterium bovis bacille Calmette-Guerin to children receiving cancer therapy and to their health care providers. Clin. Infect. Dis. 30:356-362.[CrossRef][Medline]
Journal of Clinical Microbiology, May 2008, p. 1854-1857, Vol. 46, No. 5
0095-1137/08/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/JCM.00105-07
Copyright © 2008, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
This article has been cited by other articles:
-
de Jong, E., Rentenaar, R. J., van Pelt, R., de Lange, W., Schreurs, W., van Soolingen, D., Sturm, P. D. J.
(2009). Two Cases of Mycobacterium microti-Induced Culture-Negative Tuberculosis. J. Clin. Microbiol.
47: 3038-3040
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
-
Pinsky, B. A., Banaei, N.
(2008). Multiplex Real-Time PCR Assay for Rapid Identification of Mycobacterium tuberculosis Complex Members to the Species Level. J. Clin. Microbiol.
46: 2241-2246
[Abstract]
[Full Text]